Wednesday, 7 March 2012

Be Still and Know: A Sermon


During my teenaged years I read quite a lot. Girls didn't seem that interested in me and I was too scared to ask them out anyway; I was about as far away from sporty as a person can get and, to some extent, I liked my own company and I liked the company of books. On my more philosophical days I would wander into my dad's study and because of his work as a Methodist minister this was a place with some interesting volumes. Here you would find the theology of someone like Hans Kung, the collected sermons of John Wesley or, up on the top shelf, a thriller by Alistair Maclean. Somewhere between all these things, I thought, were some big clues on what life is all about.

One day when I was about thirteen I was browsing the shelves and I came across a book of popular theology, if that's not a contradiction in terms, which contained some famous lines penned by Hughes Mearnes in 1899:

Yesterday, upon the stair,


I met a man who wasn’t there


He wasn’t there again today


I wish, I wish he’d go away...



Over the years I've heard various spoof versions, including a really stupid one in Mad Magazine:

There was a man upon the stair


When I looked back, he wasn't there


He wasn't there again today


I think he's from the CIA.

Still, in my teenaged years it was the original lines that really got to me, not in the way they were intended, as part of a play about a haunted house, but as a theological statement that spoke of my view of who or what God might be:

Yesterday, upon the stair,


I met a man who wasn’t there


He wasn’t there again today


I wish, I wish he’d go away...



As I read and later recited these words God was to me less a comfort in troubled times than a problem to be solved, a source of anguish and even fear. That this can be a person's perception of the way things are is something that I think many churches and people of faith could benefit from being more in touch with. It derives, in my opinion, from that tendency that we all inevitably have to some extent, to make God in our own image. God, whoever and whatever that might mean, is reduced to a crochety old man in the sky who thinks a bit like we do, someone who judges and condemns, someone whose love is conditional upon subscription to a particular set of beliefs. This is a human construction of God that I think leads some to be so militantly anti-religious. As a teenager I couldn't accept this idea of God, I felt deeply uncomfortable when I heard people talking on themes of heaven and hell, the need to be saved or anything like that but I took great comfort from that slim popular theology book because it used Hughes Mearnes poem to convey the idea that it was alright to have doubts, that being troubled by thoughts of who or what God might be might even be a good thing.

Fast forward a few years into my early twenties and you'll find me a little more happily a part of Methodism. By this time I had learned that whilst those with the more conservative evangelical opinions often had the loudest voices (for reasons that they sincerely believed in), other opinions were available. My searching had led me to train as a Methodist local preacher and on one Trinity Sunday I had to preach what is known as a trial sermon. In retrospect, the title was provocative. It was: The Trinity: Why stop at 3? That said, whilst the sermon generated discussion, the reaction was overwhelmingly positive and I remain grateful to those Methodist folk who were prepared to indulge me as I explored alternative perspectives. The point of that sermon was simple. Whilst mainstream Christian denominations had for centuries been wedded to the idea of God as Trinitarian – with Father, Son and Holy Spirit, this is surely not an exhaustive list of the way in which God might be viewed but is a human attempt to grasp something we don't really understand. In a theme I would return to time and time again over the years, I explored how the identification of God as inherently male was not always helpful, suggesting that it might sometimes be helpful to think, for example, of Mother God. I spoke of the desirability of inter-faith understanding and ended by saying that whilst it is great to meet in churches, and read the bible and try to follow the way of Jesus, surely the love of God is actually bigger than Christianity, bigger than any one religion.

When I was 23, I went to university and had a wonderful and inspiring time studying in York and, for a time in the United States. I was reminded of my time in America last week when I was reading an article about Rick Santorum, a very conservative thinker who has recently gained considerable support as a Republican presidential candidate. He has called American colleges 'indoctrination mills' that pursue a liberal agenda and try to get Christian students to shed their faith. Frankly, I think this view is nonsense but for me university was a time when I really came to the conclusion that there was no such thing as a bad theological question – that it really is okay to ask anything. The study of history made me question all sorts of ideas about God, particularly the idea of God as a force intervening in human history in a literal and supernatural way. Surely if God was really omnipotent, I reasoned, then God would not let terrible things happen. It has been said that you can no longer do theology without the holocaust and I would go along with that. The murder of six million Jews, thousands of homosexuals and others considered undesirably by the Nazis led many theologians to change their view of God. They began to take the emphasis off God as an all-powerful being above humanity and stress instead the idea of the presence of God within human suffering. That I thought was fine but it didn't answer the question of why God allowed terrible suffering to happen in the first place. Either God was love or God was omnipotent – to be both seemed impossible.

My journey of questioning continued in the years to come and, indeed, continues to this day. One of the things that led me to Unitarianism was that twenty years ago, when I was studying American history, I was really struck by how many of the American founding fathers were either Unitarians or heavily influenced by Unitarian thinking – Thomas Jefferson, John Quincy Adams, Benjamin Franklin all fit this description and were all driven by an attractively positive view of the world and the future. They tried to establish a new nation in which people would be really free to explore religious questions without fear of being judged. For Thomas Jefferson the separation of church and state was an invitation for people to engage in rational thinking that would bring together issues of science and religion as part of a quest for the meaning of life. He once predicted, wrongly as it turned out, that the separation of church and state would liberate people from dogmatic ways of thinking so much that by the middle of the nineteenth century Unitarianism would be the United States' dominant religious group. Even as a Methodist all that time ago, I couldn't help myself being caught up in his enthusiasm. As my study of American history continued from undergraduate to postgraduate level, the Unitarians kept coming back in politics, in the arts, in science – in practically everything I looked at and whilst they came from many different viewpoints, it seemed to me that what they had in common was an ability to really see and celebrate the beauty of this life and this world. That enthusiasm for living life so fully seemed to me to me to be a more attractive and convincing expression of the reality of 'God' than that offered by people talking constantly about heaven and hell, the depravity of human beings and so on.

In all of this time I continued to read to try to find meaning and one of the ideas that really struck me not so many years ago, was a phrase that Paul Tillich used. A problem that I had was that so long as I heard people talking about God as a being, I couldn't quite get away from the old man in the sky idea but Paul Tillich had a different take, referring to God not as a being but as 'the ground of all being.' My view of God was evolving into something more abstract but something more real – God was the glue that held everything good together, that mysterious something that allowed a person to rise above and beyond the self, the ground of all being.

Over the years my questioning ways have continued with no definitive answer in sight. Whilst I have opinions and ideas about who or what I mean when I think about God I know that most of my questions will remain unanswered. However, I take great comfort from a sermon I heard back in the late 1980s by a Methodist local preacher I trained with, Frank Bell. He credited Jesus with an extra beatitude you won't find in the gospel: 'Blessed are the cracks for they let in the light.' Of course what he meant by that is that in life we might only get very occasional glimpses of what it all means, we might experience just occasional flashes of inspiration but if we use them well, and are open to them, they can be life-changing.

I want to end with a criticism that I would certainly make of myself but you might recognise it too. As a liberal thinker there is a danger that I reduce the entirety of my religious experience to an intellectual exercise. My faith journey has been very much about books and history and trying to engage with complicated debates but that ought not to be all there is. If God is a meaningful concept then surely our emotions, consciences and whole selves must be engaged – not just our intellect.

I remember once hearing a story about a schoolboy who for reasons I can't recall ended up being taught R.E. by an atheist. The teacher was putting all his efforts into convincing this boy that there is no such thing as God – he talked about religion versus science, the big bang versus creationism, the scientific impossibility of Noah's Ark, the idea of religion as an emotional crutch and so on and so on and after he presented all his evidence he said to the boy, 'How can you possibly believe that there is a God?' The boy paused for a moment, smiled, and said, 'Because I've met Him.'

We could intellectually unpick that story but that would miss the point. Sometimes it's good to think and debate and try to look at things from every angle possible. But sometimes it is good to simply be open to the mystery that many call God. So I hope that in the quiet of this place this morning we can each draw, in our own way, meaning, hope, direction and comfort from those words we began the service with, those words from the Psalms:

Be still and know that I am God.