Thursday, 17 May 2007

The Museum of Nothing Part 2

If you found the first part of this blog annoying and devoid of any literary, social, material or philosophical value, just be thankful that you didn't live it. Lat Saturday, worn down by a week of relentless history, I decided to take my lovely wife Tracey out for a daytrip to see something historical.

You might be forgiven for thinking that a person who teaches history all week would not want more history at the weekend. However, weekend history isn't like Monday to Friday history. In the week it's all wars and rumours of wars, factions, infighting and desperation and that's just the history department meetings. Weekend history, the stuff of museums and stately homes, may deal with many of the same issues of the inhumanity of civilizations, the relentlessness of suffering in the world, or the division between those who have and those who have not but afterwards there's always a teashop with some nice cakes. So runs the theory anyway.

Thus it was with a keen sense of expectation that Tracey and I journeyed south to Southwell in Nottinghamshire to visit what the National Trust describes as 'the best preserved workhouse in England.' We drove for well over an hour to get there and made our way towards the imposing building with a certain sense of nervous anticipation. Just as at Alcatraz a few weeks earlier I felt the groans of those to whom history was not kind crowding all around me.

Tracey and I entered the workhouse almost reverently, as if we were anxious not to disturb the eternal rest of those who ended their days here. Moments later, however, we forgot about the workhouse and its former inmates when we were confronted with the National Trust woman. The National Trust seems to be in the habit of putting fierce women in charge of taking people's money off them at every opportunity. This particular woman was a zealot, a believer in the National Trust as the one true faith and hope for all humanity. She clearly was of the opinion that anyone who did not wish to become a member of the National Trust was destined to eternal damnation in the fires of hell, or worse, the wreck of an old castle run by English Heritage.

"Clearly the sensible thing to do is join the National Trust," she told us. "You won't have to pay today because we'll just take your bank details and it's only seventy two pounds for a whole year plus if you join right now you get an extra month free." There were several things wrong with this statement:

  1. 'You won't have to pay today because we'll just take your bank details.' Did she think we were completely mad? Clearly the idea of taking our bank details was that money would be extracted from our account.
  2. 'It's only seventy two pounds.' It's the word only I object to here. Seventy two pounds is a substantial amount of money with which you could buy many cakes and does not compare favourably with the admission price at Southwell of £5.50.
  3. 'It's only seventy two pounds for a whole year plus if you join right now you get an extra month free.' This is complete nonsense. The implication here is that you get thirteen months' worth of access to National Trust sites but the fact is they're hardly ever open. All you have to do is check their website for evidence of this. A person joining the National Trust is in great danger of having their hopes of year-round daytrips dashed by the small print on property websites revealing that regrettably Rakitin Manor is only open on the third Monday in July in leap years when the 29th February is on a Wednesday and New Year's Eve has a full moon.

We declined the National Trust lady's kind offer of a year's membership and she looked at us in the disdainful knowledge that we were peasants who didn't care about the heritage of England and probably approved of foreigners.

Our mood broken we entered the workhouse and began our audio tour. I've had some good experiences of audio tours in the last year, particularly at Alcatraz where the participation of both guards and prisoners really enhanced the exhibits. Herein lies the difference, however, for at Alcatraz you can see cells with furniture in, guard towers, the machinery of the control room and much more whilst at Southwell you can see very little indeed. What you get at Southwell is the experience of an imposing workhouse building and a series of nearly identical rooms WITH NOTHING IN THEM. In other words, this is a museum largely devoid of actual exhibits. The excuse is that almost no furniture has survived from Victorian workhouses so the decision was taken that rather than guessing what might have been there the National Trust would allow visitors to recreate the interior scenes of workhouse life simply by combining the power of imagination with the empty spaces they passed through.

At first I gave the exhibition the benefit of the doubt but it soon occurred to me that Tracey and I had travelled for an hour-and-a half to look at empty rooms. Furthermore, the audio tour was a work of (dull) fiction which turned out not to be based too closely on archival material of the workhouse even though such materials exist. Indeed, the highlight of this tour was a brief respite from the dramatisation in which a restoration worker talked about how many layers of whitewash you could see on the walls. This then, was the museum of nothing and it occurred to me that I could almost certainly have done a better job of recreating workhouse life by staying home and reading a book or even surfing the net. Indeed, I would maintain that a lecture I gave to some Japanese students at Sheffield University a couple of years ago on poverty in the Victorian age did a better job of recreating the mood of the workhouse than this actual workhouse did. The people at Southwell could do a great deal. There could be exhibits on the workhouse in popular culture, a day in the life of a workhouse, a kitchen tasting experience but instead there are empty rooms without exhibits. Clearly the philosophy is that it is better to have nothing than to risk losing authenticity.

There are a few rooms with exhibits in towards the end but by then it was a lost cause for me. Furthermore, I was hungry and there was no cafĂ©, not even a snack bar, not even a Mr Bumble from whom to beg for a bowl of gruel. Still as I sit in the comfort of this late nineteenth / early twentieth century house, I wonder if I might turn it into my own museum of nothing. For a limited time I could offer thirteen months' access for just £72, an audio tour detailing amusing things one of the cats did to my smelly shoe and, for a modest fee, I might go the extra mile and offer cups of tea and even biscuits. The Museum of Nothing could just about work in this house except for one thing. There are too many interesting exhibits.

The Museum of Nothing Part 1